Read the full feedback with timestamps at https://akton.one/pt/shadow-dungeon-by-oo-cat/ (optimized!) or below!
Playtest Type: Blind (First-time player with zero prior knowledge). This mimics the real launch experience to see if players get confused and abandon the game early.
Focus areas: Onboarding clarity, UI/UX, combat feedback, progression pacing, and game feel.
In case you feel like you want to support me helping my cause: ☕ https://ko-fi.com/akton1
In case you are a dev, like my report and would like me to test your game: https://ko-fi.com/akton1/commissions
If you want to start playtesting and get a bit of money, I have good experience with Play2Review, this is my referral link: https://play2review.com/auth?mode=signup&ref=349D6B86
💭 Playtest afterthoughts
Shadow Dungeon isnt the strongest of names 🧙♂️
🎬 Trailer & Presentation
Exceptional overall art direction and visual appeal create strong first impression (0:07)
High quantity of gear/build promises communicated clearly but not yet felt early (0:42)
Main character art style mismatch vs environment and enemies reduces cohesion (3:02, 8:35)
⏱ First 5 Minutes Impression
Initial curiosity driven by visuals, but early confusion about controls and mechanics (5:13, 19:12)
Lack of clear onboarding or direction creates uncertainty about goals (20:14)
Weak early combat feedback reduces immediate engagement (15:22)
Empty spell slots look like melee and can confuse (5:45)
🧭 Onboarding, Goals & Feedback
Critical lack of tutorialization for hotkeys, systems, and general flow (19:39)
No clear objective or guidance after entering the game world (20:14)
Important UI elements (like arrows/direction) are easy to miss (4:29)
Skill progression and unlocking paths are unclear (45:43)
🔥 Fun Factors & Peak Moments
Spell visuals and aura effects are highly satisfying visually (14:02)
Certain spells (e.g. priest-type abilities) feel more impactful and engaging (34:49)
Large enemy scale (ogres) creates strong visual excitement (51:37)
Boss presentation and initial visuals feel strong and promising (56:54)
💡Ideas
Increase combat feedback with stronger hit reactions, particles, and sound design (15:22, 36:03)
Improve main character animation with more dynamic movement and weight (10:03)
Align main character art style with world/enemy quality (3:02, 27:27)
Introduce early challenge spikes or difficulty variation (41:29)
Rework early skill availability to prioritize more satisfying abilities first (34:49)
Add clearer UI indicators for equipped items in comparison screens (30:10)
Improve readability and reduce padding in dialogue UI (28:14)
Add map navigation tools and clear hotkeys for core systems (43:44)
Consider better potion keybind placement for accessibility (47:17)
Increase environmental variety earlier to avoid visual monotony (53:48)
Add mid-transition areas (e.g. towns, landmarks) to break up pacing (54:12)
Increase size (27:06)
🐞 Bugs / Crashes
Spell origin point visually disconnected from weapon (13:01)
🎯 Game Loop & Motivation
Core loop shows potential through builds, loot, and spells, but lacks early engagement (0:42)
Low difficulty and lack of resource pressure reduce sense of progression (22:26, 41:29)
Limited early variety and unclear progression paths weaken motivation (53:48)
😴 Boredom Threshold
Low challenge and repetitive environments reduce engagement over time (41:29, 53:48)
Combat lacking impact leads to reduced long-term satisfaction (15:22)
👍What works well
Strong and appealing art direction overall (0:07)
High-quality enemy design and animations (8:09, 10:24)
Excellent spell visuals and particle effects (14:02)
Fast and smooth loading experience (33:26)
Readable and responsive dialogue system (28:10)
⚠️Biggest friction points
Main character animation and visual quality feel behind the rest of the game (10:03, 8:35)
Combat lacks impactful feedback and physicality (15:22, 36:03)
Onboarding and guidance are insufficient or missing (19:39, 20:14)
Game difficulty is too low, removing tension and engagement (41:29, 57:18)
UI clarity issues in inventory and controls (30:10, 47:17)
Lack of early variety in environments (53:48)
#indiegamedev #gamedev #playtest #uxdesign #indiegame #arpg #feedback #gamedesign